I’m trying something new with October’s batch of book reviews. The first review is twice as long as usual so that I could go into more depth on the important history of voting rights in America. I think I’ll try doing this again when the subject warrants it. As for the rest, it’s more poetry, science, and faith stuff, which is pretty typical for me. [edit: I’ve added another review at the bottom of a scary comic book I read on Halloween but didn’t have time to review until a few days later]
- Give Us the Ballot: The Modern Struggle for Voting Rights in America by Ari Berman is a vital look at the history of the Voting Rights Act from its passage in 1965 until today. It traces the many challenges to the law, the Supreme Court decisions that defined how the law could be interpreted, and ultimately how the law has been rendered mostly toothless by the recent Shelby County v. Holder decision in 2013. It’s easy to think that when constitutional amendments or major legislative victories pass that they have solved the problems, but it’s not like those who were on the losing side of the argument suddenly give up at that point. The 15th amendment, ratified in 1870, prohibited all levels of government from denying the vote to any citizen based on “race, color, or previous condition of servitude.” But after Reconstruction ended in 1877, the south passed numerous Jim Crow laws that essentially denied the vote to African Americans through the use of poll taxes, literacy tests, and the like. For nearly one hundred years, the constitution was not enforced. The Voting Rights Act was passed in 1965 with bipartisan support and signed by Lyndon B. Johnson after the dramatic march from Selma to Montgomery illustrated the extreme lengths that the state of Alabama was willing to go to deny the vote to blacks (the recent film Selma does a fantastic job showing the efforts of civil rights protesters). But again, those who lost the battle of the VRA did not give up the war against minority voting. For instance, say a city had 60% white people and 40% black people and had heretofore always elected a white city council by suppressing the black vote. But now that blacks could register to vote because of the VRA, they had the opportunity to elect, say, two black city council members because two of these hypothetical districts were majority black. In such a case, many cities switched from having district voting to citywide at-large voting so they could continue voting in an all white city council. This type of effort to dilute or further suppress the black vote continued to happen in the southern counties covered by the VRA after it was passed. Both Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan courted southern states by promising to water down the VRA in what has been termed the southern strategy. Reagan even went so far as to fill the Justice Department with lawyers who were not eager to enforce the VRA, including some who were outright hostile towards the law such as future Supreme Court Justices John Roberts and Samuel Alito. Other methods of suppressing minority voting include voter roll purges (where voters are removed from the registration list in an effort to update the rolls, but often leads to errors where lawfully registered voters are removed for no good reason) and voter ID laws (promoted to prevent in person voter fraud, a problem that does not in fact exist, but which hurts minority, student, and elderly voters who may not have the required identifications). In the 2000 election, the Florida recount made famous the confusing butterfly ballots and hanging chads that made it difficult to determine who received more votes in the presidential election. What got less attention was the voter roll purge that took place before the election. Florida purged the names of ex-felons (because by law in FL they did not have the right to vote), but they did so even if the names were a 70% match. That means that even if voters had a different middle initial or suffix or even their race or sex data didn’t match, they might be purged. The company that did the work for FL later went through the names again using stricter criteria and found 12,000 names that shouldn’t have been purged. Some of those people definitely tried to vote but were not able to because when they showed up at the polls, they were turned away since they were no longer registered based on mistakenly being identified as a felon. More recently, Indiana’s 2008 voter ID law was found constitutional despite zero instances of in person voter fraud in the state. After the Shelby County decision in 2013, which struck down section 4 of the VRA, numerous states that had been under the VRA rushed to try and pass voter ID laws. Section 4 of the VRA used a formula to stipulate which counties in the country would be subject to preclearance by the Justice Department of changes in election laws. With no formula, the preclearance portion of Section 5 was rendered inert. The Republican controlled Congress, despite overwhelmingly reauthorizing the VRA in 2006, has made no effort to rewrite the formula since the Shelby decision in 2013. In general, Republicans do not come out looking great in this book based on their actions, with a few exceptions like Everett Dirksen, Bob Dole, and James Sensenbrenner, who respectively each played a role in passing the VRA and renewing it in 1982 and 2006. However, I did not care for the few times Berman took cheap shots at Republicans based on irrelevant details or issues not involved in voting rights (e.g. mentioning that John Ashcroft spent taxpayer money to cover a statue of Lady Liberty at an event or insinuating that Hans von Spakovsky has a sinister sounding name). It didn’t happen often, but it hurts his credibility in telling the vital history of voting rights in America.
- The Disappearing Spoon: And Other True Tales of Madness, Love, and the History of the World from the Periodic Table of Elements by Sam Kean is a fascinating tour through the elements. True to its title, Kean’s book includes interesting stories and anecdotes for every entry on the periodic table, from the probable zinc mixed with King Midas’s bronze (itself an alloy of tin and copper) that made it a much shinier brass and perhaps mistaken for gold to the effects of lithium on the brain of a poet like Robert Lowell (e.g. resetting the circadian rhythm). Kean goes out of his way to include humor and arcane tidbits as he tells his stories. It’s partly a history of science, but it also touches on other historical events when an element plays a prominent role. I never took a chemistry class in high school or college, so I feel a little behind in my scientific understanding, but this is the kind of book that goes down easy. It’s science for the rest of us. I found myself dipping into the book frequently, and having a hard time putting it down as each new story sounded alluring. I’d recommend this grab bag of chemistry to anyone who finds science interesting. My only (admittedly minor) complaint is that there isn’t really an overall theme or point to the book beyond being a delightful collection of diverse stories about or related to the elements. The title of the book refers to gallium, a moldable metal that melts at 84 degrees, so that a teaspoon made of gallium would literally melt in a hot beverage as a nerdy prank. Oh, science!
- Transformations by Anne Sexton is an off-kilter poetry collection retelling familiar fairy tales. The stories from Grimm may be familiar, but the tone and the telling are decidedly fresh and exciting. Take the scene in “Cinderella,” where the sisters are trying on the slipper:The eldest went into a room to try the slipper on
but her big toe got in the way so she simply
sliced it off and put on the slipper.
The prince rode away with her until the white dove
told him to look at the blood pouring forth.
That is the way with amputations.
They don’t just heal up like a wish.
The other sister cut off her heel
but the blood told as blood will.
The prince was getting tired.
He began to feel like a shoe salesman.
But he gave it one last try.
This time Cinderella fit into the shoe
like a love letter into its envelope.But it’s not long before the lovely image of the letter and envelope are undercut by Cinderella and the prince living happily ever after “like two dolls in a museum case” with “their darling smiles pasted on for eternity.” (read the whole poem here) Many other tales such as “Rapunzel,” “Snow White,” and “The Frog Prince” get the same sardonic treatment. I especially enjoyed some of the tales that I wasn’t already familiar with like “One-eye, Two-eyes, Three-eyes.” It’s a deeply weird meditation on parenthood and disability in which three sisters each have a different number of eyes. The odd-eyed sisters are favored by their mother, and the normal two-eyed girl is an outcast. Of course, in the usual manner, that means she will come out on top through magic and the love of a knight. But Sexton frames the tale with the deeply conflicted thoughts of parents dealing with children with disabilities. Parents can see their child as a gift from God, a cosmic mistake, a cause for martyrdom, or a millstone around the neck. The tale ends with Two-Eyes taking in her sisters out of pity and because they are like magic talismans. She can’t help but have them. It’s a poem that I’ll be returning to again and again out of sheer fascination. I’d recommend this book for anyone who likes fairy tales.
- The Underground Church: Reclaiming the Subversive Way of Jesus by Robin Meyers is a provocative look at church. The main problem with the church, as Meyers sees it, is that it has been co-opted by Empire (first the Roman Empire under Constantine, today the American church by the government and/or political parties). He outlines ways in which the church should disentangle from Empire and get back to its roots as a countercultural force. Meyers envisions followers of Jesus from all denominations and theological beliefs coming together to live the faith that we profess. To him, faith is not a list of beliefs, but radically embodied trust, or “an orientation toward the mystery of God [… b]ecause we trust in spite of what we cannot know” (118). Another key element for Meyers is that the Underground Church he envisions is nonviolent: we are called to peace and to love our enemies. It’s something that has been lost from many Christian traditions outside of the Quakers, Mennonites, and Amish (and perhaps a few others). He has lots of other ideas about how the church can be true to its roots: by making communion an actual meal that is shared with not only the congregation but also with any who may be hungry and in need, by budgeting as much money for outreach as for keeping the lights on and staff paid, by standing up against injustice wherever it may be, and by taking care of God’s creation and not exploiting it out of greed and selfishness, among many others. I felt convicted by some of his exhortations. I really liked his sense of shared mission in living out unconditional love no matter what church background. For myself, I’ve found a home in the Episcopal church. But just recently my mom was telling me about the wonderful after school program for inner city kids that her evangelical church (the one I grew up in) has been running for close to 15 years. We may not see eye to eye on every bit of theology, but she and her church are showing the love of God to those kids. My only complaint about the book is that I wanted Meyers to provide more depth to some of his historical analyses. I appreciated what he did say about the early church and the time of Constantine, but I wanted more. I thought the idea of church being co-opted by Empire important so I wanted even more analysis. His book read more like extended sermons, though, which makes sense since he is a pastor. He comes from the United Church of Christ, so though he wants to find common ground with Christians of all stripes, it might be harder for those who are more conservative to overlook some of his more liberal statements. But I think it’s worth the effort in trying to find common ground with other Christians if we truly want to love God and our neighbors. [Disclosure: I received the book from the Carol Mann Agency via a Goodreads giveaway in the hopes that I would give it an honest review.]
- Wytches Volume 1, written by Scott Snyder and penciled by Jock, is a pretty terrifying horror comic book. Primarily, it’s the story of a family who has moved to a small town in New England in an attempt to start over. The mother is still recovering from an accident that confines her to a wheelchair, the father needs time and space to work, and their daughter Sailor is trying to start over after a terrible confrontation with a bully in her old town. But the past cannot be outrun. And there is something evil in the woods, something old that preys on human greed and selfishness. These aren’t the witches of Oz or Macbeth, but something more primal and awful. But it’s not just a story of confronting evil, but a story of confronting limits, the limits of a parent in protecting a child, or the limits of a teenager’s control of anxiety. The story is well paced, divided as it is in six parts (originally it was published in single issue comic books, each with an effective cliffhanger). It was hard to put down. Also, I was glad I read it during the day so I didn’t have to think about the scary parts in the dark. The artwork by Jock has two modes: during daylight it is fairly realistic, but when it is dark or there are supernatural elements, the artwork becomes more jagged and exaggerated, like it is more about the sensation of the characters or setting rather than their literal presentation. The art is a perfect match for Snyder’s story. The book also contains some extra material at the end that allows the reader to see some of the process of the artwork from penciling to the finished product. From this material it becomes clear that the colorist Matt Hollingsworth is also a vital member of the team to make this story work. Though Wytches is an ongoing work, this first volume can be read as a standalone story with a clear climax and ending to this part of the story. Having said that, I’ll be eager to find out where it goes next. I’d recommend this to anyone who likes scary stories.